So, my lovely wife got me an iPod touch for Christmas (me likey).
I’ve had an iPod since the first iPod ad video came out.
(I wasn’t really intrigued by the first iPods, as they were out of my price range at the time, but I digress.) Now that I have enough room on my iPod for the entire Rush discography and then some, I need to make sure I can hear every nuance of Neil Peart’s drum solos….just in case I decide to relive my youth and buy back my black 12-piece double-base Ludwig drumset with black Paiste cymbals (those were the days).
Before I start with my review, I have to confess, I have small oddly shaped ears. Don’t laugh, people, it’s an affliction that doesn’t allow me to wear earbuds; and most in-ear buds just slip out. So I’m relegated to wearing headphones (or cans, as they say in the biz 🙂 ).
I was about to pull the trigger on some rather expensive headphones, until the guy at BestBuy tried to sell me the “extra-special-we-fix-everything” warranty. I told the guy that these things cost more than the iPod I’ll be listening to so they shouldn’t break. He then went further to explain where and what breaks on these Super-Duper headphones.
WOW…..I’m out; and didn’t get those headphones.
So I’m looking at two different pairs of headphones. While still relatively expensive (I’m kind of a snob. I can’t help myself!), I’m looking at the Dr. Dre Beats Studio’s and the Bose QC 15’s. Both require batteries to work, have noise cancelling and have a pretty nice case.
Dr. Dre has style
My neighbor, a 15 year-old kid, just bought the Beats Studio headphones. I brought over my iPod and really went through my vast array of music to see what I thought. The look of these things are neat. His happened to be black, but you can get them in white. They seemed sturdy enough and comfort was good. I’m not too worried about what they look like, but comfort is important. I went through my list of usuals: Bob Marley, Bach, Flogging Molly, Led Zepplin, Lynyrd Skynyrd, Matisyahu, and of course…..RUSH. I really wanted to like these headphones, but unfortunately, with my diverse musical tastes, it just wasn’t meant to be. The sound on these things was amazing, but it’s the nuances that got me. Matisyahu ROCKED! It’s Rap, so it should have a lot of bass. However, that amount of bass really made Bac and any of the Rock music sound muddy. The Beats just lacked the dynamic range that I wanted, even after playing with the EQ settings on my iPod. Stinks, because I looked good in them…well okay, maybe not.
Bose is consistent
A colleague let me borrow his QC 15’s and I’m wearing them right now while I write this blog entry (THANKS, D!). Geddy Lee never sounded so good (RUSH, people – get some!). The Bose are less bulky than the Beats, and still maintain good comfort. The Noise Cancelling on these is slightly better (on an airplane, these would rock). The dynamic range of these headphones is outstanding! Switching between Southern Rock, Classical, Rap and RUSH (yes, RUSH – is it’s own music genre), I didn’t have to play with the EQ at all, they just sound consistently good.
I think if I were 20 years younger, I would really enjoy the Beats.
However, I’m 40 and I’d rather them sound good, than look “stylish”.